It should be ‘Joy in Books’, not ‘Joy of Books’

A number of people have been sharing a cool video which features animated books moving around a Toronto bookstore. It’s named ‘The Joy of Books’, and it’s a well-made, enjoyable creation which is fun to watch, as you can now see:

But possibly as a result of the title, a few people are using it as an example of why print is in some way superior to an electronic version.

And that’s rubbish, quite frankly.

There are two elements of books that elicit joy:

  • What’s in the book
  • What surrounds the book

None of that is inherent to print, eReaders, parchment, hieroglyphics or any other transportation medium.
Wall of Books

What’s in the book:

Amazing writing and art will bring someone joy. I’m happy reading William Gibson books in print or on my Kindle, and if he decided in the future that he would only inscribe his work into the trunks of trees, I’d be trying to find a way to fund a private forest in my back garden.

As long as the typeface is legible, and the art is clear, then the transportation of it matters not a jot. Possibly my last line of resistance was comics and graphic novels, but even in this case I’ve overcome my reservations about reading them electronically when I’ve been borrowing an iPad. And as always, great writing and art works.

That doesn’t mean that there aren’t things that could be improved – reading a PDF on a Kindle can be frustrating when the text and font aren’t suited, but PDFs have always been the work of the devil regardless of how you’re forced to encounter them.
Christopher Moore book signing

What surrounds the book:

Here’s where it gets more interesting. So the first aspect to transfer between formats is the social aspect. Reading to my son from a printed book or a Kindle doesn’t matter in terms of the benefit and enjoyment he gets from someone reading to him. Chatting about the book with other people isn’t diminished by a screen, and lending is a possibility now. In fact, electronically I can share Creative Commons books directly with friends around the globe, ensuring they can read the same ‘copy’ as me.

There are differences in the physical sensation. It’s not so much the turning on a page – the way buttons work to flick through a book on the Kindle is a pretty damn effective substitute. But particularly the smell of an aging book hasn’t been replicated electronically (Although it easily could). Not sure that’s a particularly great source of joy though – more an association that old paper quite often comes with great stories.

Then there are two tangible areas which reflect the hoarding of knowledge – the receiving of a book as a treasured gift, and resale value. The resale value of most books is negligible thanks to the massive inventory of mainstream paperbacks, so it really only applies to niche hardbacks.

And then we come to gifting – particularly if it’s a family heirloom or with handwritten notes. That’s the only area in which culturally it’s hard to put the same weighting on an electronic version, but that shift will undoubtedly happen to some extent, leaving either small inventories of the most popular gift choices in print editions, or print-on-demand for anything which isn’t in a classic gift choice.
kindle_etch04

Either way, the pleasure of the contents, the social aspect of sharing and discussing, and many of the other areas of enjoyment when it comes to literature are already present in electronic formats, and some of the others could be closely replicated. That’s why the joy is ‘in’ the book, not ‘of’ the book.

This week I have mostly…

Over the past few weeks and months I’ve been on a major de-cluttering spree, which has particularly focused on my pop culture addiction. I’ve sold, donated and binned a fairly substantial amount of books and videos, with CD’s and DVD’s either ripped and archived or in the queue to be added with the next external hard drive purchase.

The net result is that I’ve made a small amount of cash by letting go of books I’d probably never read again, I’ve gained some space and perspective on what is actually most important to me, and I’ve been investing in more digital formats for the future. The only downside is that one of my favourite habits is to check out the books/films/cds whenever I visit someone’s house, which doesn’t work so well in the digital age. Hence a quick top-of-the-head list of my entertainment for the previous week (For more comprehensive lists, you can always check out Last.fm, Goodreads, etc, but some items either don’t appear or get forgotten…)

I’ve been reading:

Since getting a Kindle, I’ve devoured Bad Science by Ben Goldacre, which I’d meant to read for ages, and finally picked up. Not only is it extremely interesting for those with an interest in medicine and science, but it should also be essential reading for any journalist and writer who has ever had to deal with a press release containing data, technical terms, or plain BS. And it’s a pretty damning report on the state of national news reporting when it comes to big medical stories.

I also raised through With a Little Help by Cory Doctorow. Like Bad Science, I’d meant to read it for ages, and indeed had started via the Creative Commons edition that Cory makes available for free via his website, but to enjoy it outside of a PDF on my laptop I figured I’d pay the ‘Lazy tax’ to have the Kindle version.

It’s a great collection of short stories, and although some did appeal more than others, what is always consistent is that every Doctorow tale comes with insight and inspiration for the future of the internet/society/technology etc. Even an average Doctorow story gets you thinking, and there are a number in here which are way above average. If there were two authors I’d subscribe to for all future work sight unseen, it’d be Cory and William Gibson.

And finally I’m just finishing the Tao of Jeet Kune Do by Bruce Lee – something which I’ve always meant to read but never enough to make it to the top of my list when in a bookshop. But it seemed like good timing, having rekindled my interest in actually practising some martial arts again by The Pajama Game, rather than just watching the occasional film. It’s interesting because it’s not a ‘how to’ guide for individual punches and throws – it’s a sometimes random collection of notes loosely structured after Lee’s death into the philosophy and approach of a fighting style which has no fixed style. And I also happened to read this post by Charles Frith which features an interesting interview with Lee.

I’ve been listening:

In a shocking lack of awareness, I’d seen Laura Kidd occasionally being mentioned in reference to her fanbase on Twitter, but hadn’t actually got around to listening to her music until she recently released an album of remixes in aid of charity. That prompted me to check out her album Disarm (on Amazon, and on Spotify), under the name ‘She Makes War’.

Turns out I’m an idiot, she makes brilliant music including a free downloadable cover of ‘I Think We’re Alone Now’ which is now the version I’ll hear when someone mentions the song.

I’ve been watching:

Aside from catching the odd episode of Big Bang Theory and a passing interest in Man vs Food, the only thing I actually wanted to watch when it was being broadcast was Sherlock Holmes. At which point my parents decided to have their weekend telephone call, so I haven’t really watched anything this week. And luckily my strange soap opera obsession with Ice Road Truckers Deadliest Roads ended just before this week so you’ll never find out about it.

I will get around to watching Borgen, but will probably end up waiting for the complete series to become available rather than watching weekly – I’ve increasingly found it’s easier for me to spend a weekend immersed in a series rather than waiting impatiently for scheduling to mean that I get out of sync anyway.

In terms of films, there hasn’t really been anything grabbing me – I did catch random bits of films I’d already seen being broadcast yet again, such as watching Oceans 12 for long enough to remember why it was such a letdown. But I did end up watching the Smurfs, which combine Neil Patrick Harris with what has to be the best role Hank Azaria has played – normally his appearance in a film is a guarantee of slight irritation at a slightly annoying pastiche. One that kept a 3-year-old entertained enough whilst his parents could also enjoy it.

I’ve been playing:

Rather than television, any leisure time goes into the Xbox. The social side of Xbox Live defines most of this, with my current Forza Motorsport 4 obsession combining a group of friends and the still-present ambition to find a way to race regularly. I’ve also had a very short blast on Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3, but it still hasn’t grabbed me as addictively as the previous games in the series.
Besides that I’ve finally been catching up on the downloadable content available for Grand Theft Auto 4, particularly now I know there’s a new one on the way, and also been slowly making my way through the Wild West version in Red Dead Redemption. Both are massive, epic games with enough storytelling elements to replace television and films, with the added advantages of interactivity and being able to pursue the areas and choices that interest me.

Libraries could really be up the creek…

I actually toned down the headline (the original one rhymed with ‘ducked’). The reason for this bleak prognosis?

Well, first I wrote about the potential of the ebook to remove the relevance of libraries and how they could adapt.

Two days later, Amazon allowed websites and bloggers to start embedding the opening chapter of books - not a major nail in the coffin, but an indication.

But now it’s done.

Later this year, Amazon owners will be able to lend out their books to other Kindle owners for 14 days. That’s the same functionality which is also available on the Barnes & Noble Nook.

Now, there are restrictions and rules, not every book will be available, and the Kindle-owning population is by far the minority. But there’s also a two-week limit on physical library books, not every book is available, and there are restrictions and fines.

And as detailed in the external link below, there appears to be a successful trial in the U.S using e-readers as I suggested a while ago.

Enhanced by Zemanta

Makers by Cory Doctorow

I don’t often review books on here, and I review fiction books even less, but Makers is definitely a worthwhile exception, as Cory Doctorow is well-known both as an author, and for his views and work on copyright and open rights. Although Makers might be a work of fiction, it’s very much written as a parable based on his views.

Before I go into the book itself, it’s worthwhile noting that you can download it for free in almost every conceivable e-format and licensed under Creative Commons from Cory’s site, as well as buying the print version in the normal manner from the usual retailers ( such as Amazon – Makers
aff link). As he has often documented (Including in his non-fiction essay collection, Content), the evidence he has points towards this approach helping him towards increased print sales.

Makers:

Makers follows the progress of a handful of key characters in a near future world, where technology has continued to progress, business strategies have remained the same, but the economy has gotten worse for many people.

Following the fictional merger of Kodak and Duracell, the new boss of Kodacell, Kettlewell, introduces a new scheme to support micro-business, and the first of these are two creative hacker-types, Perry and Lester, working out of a disused Florida mall next to a shantytown, and creating tech and art out of salvaged junk and 3D printers. They’re joined by Suzanne Church, a journalist encouraged to document the story, and Tjan, a business manager flown in by Kettlewell.

MakersbyCoryDoctorow

The book follows the story of their project, and their lives, as they have an effect on the community around them, and indeed the American country – and the effect on them when big business perceives them as a threat.

It’s a great book for anyone with enthusiasm for technology, whether it’s about geek tech, DIY or Steampunk – and it’s also great to pass onto those in your life who might not get your enthusiasm for tech, open source and microbusiness.

But it’s not Open Source propaganda – quite often Lester and Perry can infuriate those around them – and readers – by clinging to their desire to ‘just make things’, and not to embrace the events happening around them, despite the publicity they get from Suzanne’s journalism – which itself develops into a successful self-published business of its own.

A work of fiction and the suspension of disbelief is the reason you don’t see imitators with more of a business angle take over from the pair, until Disney figures late in the story.

The characters in the story are all based within recognisable stereotypes – the overweight geek, the mature female reporter, the youthful CEO and the efficient business manager – but just as in meeting people in real life, they contain personality and character much beyond this.

Overall, it’s an excellent book and page-turner. I downloaded it as a free PDF and ended up forsaking my RSS feed (and this blog), for a couple of days until I’d finished it. If you’re the geeky sort, you’re love the mix of tech invention and the recognisable possible future of the current tech ideals and businesses (and there are plenty of geek jokes in there). And if you’re trying to kickstart some enthusiasm amongst non-geek friends, it’s the perfect fictional introduction – it’s even useful for business owners and managers as a guide to a possible future and a spark for ideas which may work successfully.

Only two negatives (spoiler alert):

Only two short sections left me cold – one was a detailed sex scene (as forewarned in Cory’s introduction to the PDF copy). It wasn’t the sex itself, or the detailed descriptions – it was the fact that it seemed so out of place and jarred with the rest of the book. Maybe the point is that the physical relationships between Perry, Lester and the other characters was so hard for the two hacker geeks to maintain compared to their relationship with technology and their creations, but it really felt as if the 2 or so pages detailing the carnal act were forced in there (pardon the single entendre).

The only other disappointment was the ending, which was a major issue considering the quality of the rest of the book, but it left me somewhat underwhelmed. Not because it was a less than triumphant finish for the people involved, but because the way it was delivered – particularly the ‘hadn’t seen each over in years’ mechanic. Technology has removed this from being as plausible in the modern world, and the events leading up to their separation never seem quite enough to cause an active attempt by the pair to avoid each other (in real life people do drift apart without any effort, but for fiction to make this interesting would take a far longer book and a different angle). It made for an ending which felt more like it a conclusion was needed, than naturally followed the events so far.

Overall? Download it and Buy it!

Minor gripes aside, I really loved Makers, and it’s good enough that the minor gripes are an extremely small price to pay for the rest of the book. If you download the free version from the main Makers website, I’m willing to bet you’ll be buying at least a couple of the print editions for yourself, and for friends and family (Makers
Amazon affiliate link).